Conversations With Sri Ramakrishna (cd)

(1 reviews)
  • Conversations With Sri Ramakrishna (cd)
translated by Sachindra Kumar Majumdar

Now you can read the words of Sri Ramakrishna as M. (Mahendranath Gupta) recorded them in his diaries from 1882 through 1886.

  • Digital CD suitable for PC or MAC
  • (retail only)

Now you can read the words of Sri Ramakrishna as M. (Mahendranath Gupta) recorded them in his diaries from 1882 through 1886. We offer two alternate translations: One is  Sw. Nikhilananda's polished Gospel of Sri Ramakrishna. There is also another unedited translation titled the Sri Sri Ramakrishna Kathamritta.

Conversations With Sri Ramakrishna is a word-for-word translation into English of Ramakrishna's conversations as they occurred. The translation was written out in longhand virtually without erasure or correction and appears in exact form as the translator, Sachindra Kumar Majumdar, took it off the pages of M.'s five volumes published in Bengali. 

No attempt has been made to polish or edit Ramakrishna's words. Nothing has been added, nothing taken away in approximately 1,400 pages of text. 

The reader should understand that the translation lacks the polish and beauty of the Nikhilananda translation of the Gospel. An added problem is that when translating from one culture to another, it is easy to mis-understand the context or the meaning. Ramakrishna may appear crude or vulgar at some places, when in context, that is not what is going on. 

The translator, Sachindra Kumar Majumdar (1909-1999), was a disciple of Swami Shivananda, the second head of the Ramakrishna Monastic Order. As a young man in Bengal, Mr. Majumdar met M. and soon began experimenting with the translation of Kathamrita into English. The wish to provide an exact and complete renderingof the original script in a manner that would have satisfied M. became almost a life-long challenge for Mr. Majumdar and culminated in this translation when he was in his eighties. 

Mr. Majumdar was an independent pioneer in the teaching of yoga practices and Vedanta philosophy in the West. He was a swami of the Ramakrishna Order for many years, and came to the US as an assistant to Swami Nikhilananda. For various reasons, he left the order and taught Yoga independently. This CD is truly compatable with a PC or MAC. You will need Adobe Reader (which is on the CD) to view the material. All the power of Adobe Reader is available, including cut and paste, and search.


Global Rating: 4.00 from 1 reviews
Review By Brother William

Almost Accurate

Mazumdar's translation is far more accurate than Nikhilananda's, mostly conveying Ramakrishna's earthy style of speaking and preserving M's soliloquies. However, Mazumdar commits some of the same omissions that Nikhilananda committed whenever Ramakrishna's language is sexually explicit or vague. Ramakrishna habitually utilized sexual humor among men devotees, usually to comic effect, thus making highly memorable points about high spiritual themes. This makes him feel much more approachable and appealing in the original Bengali, conveying the sense that high spirituality is for everyone, not just for “goodie-goodies and school marms.” His language is frankly vulgar at times, but its impact is edifying. Furthermore, Ramakrishna habitually addressed men devotees with a word that can best be translated into English as “dear” or “sweetie,” a word normally only used between spouses or lovers or among women friends. Neither Nikhilananda nor Mazumdar translates this, and so this aspect of Rama